Rest API vs GraphQL: Explained and Compared

Looking for a Postman alternative?

Try APIDog, the Most Customizable Postman Alternative, where you can connect to thousands of APIs right now!

Download Apidog

Introduction

In today’s digital world, APIs play a crucial role in connecting and integrating various applications and systems. Two popular technologies that facilitate this integration are REST API and GraphQL. While both have their merits, it is important to understand the differences between them and choose the one that best suits your use case. In this article, we will explore the fundamentals of REST API and GraphQL, compare their key features, and discuss factors to consider when choosing between them.

Definition of REST API

REST (Representational State Transfer) API is an architectural style for designing networked applications. It provides a set of guidelines and constraints that enable systems to communicate over the internet. As a developer, you design RESTful APIs by defining resources and using HTTP methods (GET, POST, PUT, DELETE) to interact with these resources. RESTful APIs are stateless, meaning that each request from a client to the server is independent and does not carry any context.

Definition of GraphQL

GraphQL, on the other hand, is a query language and runtime for APIs. It was developed by Facebook and has gained significant popularity due to its flexibility and efficiency. Unlike REST API, which returns fixed data structures, GraphQL allows clients to ask for exactly what they need and receive that data in a single request. This reduces over-fetching and under-fetching of data, making GraphQL an excellent choice for mobile applications and complex web applications.

Many industry giants, such as Twitter and Expedia, have adopted GraphQL due to its powerful features and ability to optimize API performance. In fact, Twitter reported a 40% reduction in the number of API requests after migrating from REST to GraphQL. This serves as a testament to the advantages of using GraphQL over traditional REST API.

Importance of Comparing REST API and GraphQL

As developers, it is essential to compare different technologies and choose the one that best fits our requirements. REST API and GraphQL both have their unique strengths and weaknesses, and understanding these differences will help us make informed decisions. In the following sections, we will delve into the fundamental concepts of REST API and GraphQL, and then compare their key features to bring out the contrasting aspects of the two technologies.

REST API Fundamentals

REST API follows a set of architectural constraints that help in building scalable and modular applications. It uses HTTP requests to enable clients to access and use data from servers. The foundation of REST API is centered around the following key principles:

1. Resources: In REST API, everything is a resource. A resource can be a physical entity, a logical entity, or an abstract concept. For example, in an e-commerce application, products, customers, and orders can be considered as resources.
2. HTTP Methods: CRUD (Create, Retrieve, Update, Delete) operations in REST API are performed using HTTP methods. The most commonly used methods are:

• GET: Retrieve a resource or a collection of resources.
• POST: Create a new resource.
• PUT: Update an existing resource.
• DELETE: Delete a resource.

1. URL Structure: REST API relies on a hierarchical URL structure to identify and fetch resources. For example, /products/123 can be used to retrieve a specific product with an ID of 123.
2. Headers: REST API allows the client and server to exchange additional information through headers. These headers can be used for caching, AB testing, authentication, and more.

To interact with a REST API, the client submits an HTTP request to the server. The server processes the request and sends back an HTTP response containing the requested data. This client-server interaction plays a vital role in REST API design and development.

GraphQL Fundamentals

GraphQL, as mentioned earlier, is a query language and runtime for APIs. It provides a complete description of the data in an API and allows clients to specify which fields they need. This granular control over data retrieval is one of the main advantages of GraphQL. Let’s explore the key concepts of GraphQL:

1. Schema: GraphQL APIs are defined by a schema, which serves as a contract between the client and the server. The schema defines the available types of data, relationships between them, and the queries and mutations that can be performed on the data. The schema acts as a documentation for the API and ensures type safety.
2. Queries: In GraphQL, clients retrieve data by sending queries to the server. A query specifies the fields and relationships that the client is interested in. The server then returns the requested data, formatted as JSON, in the response. The client has full control over what data is received, reducing over-fetching and improving performance.
3. Mutations: While queries are used for retrieving data, mutations are used for modifying data on the server. Mutations can be used to create, update, or delete resources in the API. Like queries, mutations are explicitly defined in the API’s schema.
4. Subscriptions: GraphQL also supports real-time updates through subscriptions. Subscriptions allow clients to receive data in real-time whenever a specific event occurs on the server. For example, a chat application can use subscriptions to update the client with new messages as they are received.

The power of GraphQL lies in its ability to evolve over time without breaking existing clients. This is achieved through the use of the schema and the explicit definition of queries, mutations, and subscriptions. Clients can add new fields to their queries or mutations, and the server can add new fields to the schema, ensuring a seamless evolution of the API.

Key Difference: Query Language vs Architectural Concept

The key difference between REST API and GraphQL lies in their core concepts. REST API is an architectural concept that outlines how to design APIs, whereas GraphQL is a query language that allows clients to specify the exact data they need. Let’s dive deeper into this difference:

REST as an Architectural Concept

REST API is an architectural style that follows a set of principles and guidelines. It focuses on providing a uniform interface and building scalable, stateless applications. REST encourages separation of concerns and decouples the client and server. The client communicates with the server using standardized HTTP methods and receives data as a response.

By following REST principles, developers can build APIs that are easily scalable, highly performant, and easily cacheable. RESTful APIs are also language-agnostic, meaning that clients and servers can be implemented in different programming languages.

GraphQL as a Query Language

GraphQL, on the other hand, is a query language that allows clients to specify the exact data they need from the server. With GraphQL, the shape and structure of the response are determined by the client, not the server. This gives clients complete control over the data they receive and eliminates the problem of over-fetching or under-fetching data.

Moreover, GraphQL provides a strongly typed schema and allows clients to request multiple resources in a single query. This reduces the number of roundtrips between the client and the server, making GraphQL more efficient in certain scenarios.

Comparison Scenario: Fetching Student Data

To understand the practical differences between REST API and GraphQL, let’s consider a scenario where we need to fetch student data. We will compare how the same task is accomplished using both technologies.

Using REST to Fetch Student Data

In a RESTful API, we could have an endpoint like /students to retrieve a list of all students. A client can make a GET request to this endpoint and receive an array of student objects as a response. The response might look like this:

HTTP GET /students

[
  {
    "id": 1,
    "name": "John Doe",
    "age": 20,
    "major": "Computer Science"
  },
  {
    "id": 2,
    "name": "Jane Smith",
    "age": 22,
    "major": "Mathematics"
  },
  ...
]

Here, the client receives all the fields for each student, irrespective of whether they need all the fields or not. This can lead to over-fetching of data, especially if the client only needs the name and age of each student.

Using GraphQL to Fetch Student Data

With GraphQL, the client has granular control over the data it receives. The client can specify the fields it needs in the query, eliminating unnecessary data retrieval. Here’s an example GraphQL query to fetch student data:

query {
  students {
    name
    age
  }
}

In response to this query, the server would return only the requested fields for each student:

{
  "data": {
    "students": [
      {
        "name": "John Doe",
        "age": 20
      },
      {
        "name": "Jane Smith",
        "age": 22
      },
      ...
    ]
  }
}

As you can see, GraphQL allows the client to define the shape of the response, resulting in a more efficient data retrieval process. This fine-grained control over data retrieval is one of the main advantages of GraphQL over REST API.

Factors to Consider when Choosing between REST and GraphQL

When choosing between REST API and GraphQL, there are several factors that developers need to consider. Let’s explore these factors:

1. Security Considerations: Both REST API and GraphQL can be secured using standard authentication mechanisms like JSON Web Tokens (JWT). However, GraphQL allows clients to request only the data they need, reducing the risk of exposing sensitive information. REST APIs, on the other hand, may return more data than the client actually needs, increasing the surface area for potential security vulnerabilities.
2. Usability Factors: REST API is extensively documented, widely adopted, and has a mature tooling ecosystem. It is relatively easier to understand and implement, making it a good choice for simpler applications and scenarios. GraphQL, on the other hand, has a steeper learning curve but provides more flexibility and efficiency in data retrieval. It shines in complex applications where data needs are diverse and evolving.
3. Performance Considerations: GraphQL can be more efficient in certain scenarios where the client can retrieve all the required data in a single request. This eliminates the need for multiple roundtrips and reduces network overhead. REST API, on the other hand, requires multiple requests to fetch related resources, which can result in increased latency and network traffic.
4. Caching Differences: REST API has built-in caching mechanisms, such as HTTP caching, that can be leveraged to improve performance. Caching can help reduce server load and network latency by returning cached responses instead of processing the same request again. GraphQL, being a query language and runtime, does not have built-in caching mechanisms. Developers need to handle caching explicitly based on their specific requirements.
5. Error Handling Approaches: REST API typically relies on status codes to indicate error conditions. For example, a GET request that does not find a resource might return a 404 Not Found status code. GraphQL, on the other hand, treats errors as first-class citizens and includes detailed error information in the response. This makes error handling and debugging easier in GraphQL.

Considering these factors will help you choose the technology that best fits your use case. It is important to evaluate your specific requirements, understand the trade-offs, and weigh the benefits and limitations of each technology.

Conclusion

In this article, we explored the fundamental concepts of REST API and GraphQL and compared their key features. REST API is an architectural style for APIs, while GraphQL is a query language and runtime. While REST is widely adopted and has a mature tooling ecosystem, GraphQL provides more flexibility and efficiency in data retrieval.

We compared how REST API and GraphQL handle a scenario of fetching student data, highlighting the advantages of GraphQL in terms of efficiency and granular control over data retrieval. We also discussed several factors to consider when choosing between REST API and GraphQL, including security, usability, performance, caching, and error handling.

It is important to carefully evaluate your use case and requirements before making a decision. REST API and GraphQL both have their unique strengths and benefits. Choose the technology that aligns with your specific needs and provides the best developer experience for your project.

Looking for a Postman alternative?

Try APIDog, the Most Customizable Postman Alternative, where you can connect to thousands of APIs right now!

Download Apidog